MARK MAYNARD: Goodell made right call on Stallworth 6/20/09

Columns

Discussion

June 20, 2009

Anonymous The Daily Independent Sat Jun 20, 2009, 09:58 AM EDT

The other night one of my favorite baseball movies was showing on one of those obscure channels.

“Eight Men Out” is the story of the 1919 Chicago White Sox scandalous World Series with the Cincinnati Reds.

Some of the White Sox, paid nothing by owner Charlie Comiskey, got involved with gamblers and threw games in the World Series that the Reds eventually won.

The players went on trial for their deed but the pro-White Sox jury proclaimed them not guilty. They were celebrating and hugging, figuring they had beat the system.

But baseball’s judge – Commissioner Kenesaw “Mountain” Landis – had other ideas. He banned the eight who were involved in the scandal from baseball forever, including Buck Weaver and the infamous “Shoeless” Joe Jackson.

It was the right move for Landis, who saved baseball’s integrity and drew a line in the sand that the players knew they dared not cross.

Earlier this week, Cleveland Browns’ wide receiver Donte Stallworth looked like he’d beaten the system. His high-powered attorney had helped Stallworth get the deal of the century. Stallworth had killed a man while driving under the influence and his penalty for manslaughter was a mere 30 days in jail.

Stallworth, to his credit, took responsibility for the crime that killed a 59-year-old family man in Miami. But because of his decision to drive under the influence, Mario Reyes was dead. His family lost a husband and father forever.

Stallworth made a plea bargain with the family so they wouldn’t sue in civil court and the court’s guilty verdict for manslaughter resulted in the 30-day sentence. He actually only has to serve 24 days, having been credited for one day when he was arrested and then getting the sentenced reduced by five more days because of being a first-time offender.

The penalty seemed light for such a horrendous outcome for the Reyes family. Oh, I’m sure they’re financially in fine shape after making the deal with Stallworth.

But can you replace a father with money?

On Thursday, the NFL put in its penalty phase on Stallworth. NFL commissioner Roger Goodell, who protects “The Shield” aggressively, suspended Stallworth indefinitely for his “inexcusable” actions.

Goodell made the correct call and he is the NFL’s judge and jury. Playing in the NFL should be a privilege and shouldn’t come with exceptions. Stallworth made a mistake but it’s a mistake that a Miami family – and Stallworth himself – will have to live with for a lifetime.

How long the indefinite suspension lasts is anybody’s guess. But Goodell, like “Mountain” Landis did in 1919, drew a line in the sand.

Professional athletes need to understand they are responsible for their actions no matter how much money they’re making.

Goodell may be criticized for being too harsh on Stallworth but it was the right thing to do. He called the wide receiver’s actions “inexcusable.”

When Stallworth’s 30-day jail sentenced was announced earlier in the week, how many of us thought the punishment didn’t fit the crime.

Goodell apparently was thinking the same way.

MARK MAYNARD can be reached at mmaynard@dailyindependent.com or (606) 326-2648.

Text Only

Columns

Mark Maynard: Charles will be in charge: 2/9/12
It was at least mildly interesting a couple of weeks ago when the deadline for filing for local elected offices came and went without much fanfare.

February 8, 2012
John Cannon: After passion, love still grows: 2/8/12
While a naive student at Morehead State University more than 40 years ago, my then girlfriend made me an offer I could not refuse. It was only later that I learned I should have refused it.

February 7, 2012
Cathie Shaffer: All that’s old is new again: 02/07/12
Every night before I go to bed, I click on my electric blanket. There’s nothing I like better on a cold — OK, lately, it’s been coolish — night than a nice, warm bed.

February 7, 2012
Tim Preston: Art downtown, ‘hippie’ soap, Valentine’s and living-dead machines: 02/05/12
I’m not certain this is anything that could be classified as a trend, although I have noticed something in downtown Ashland I am compelled to encourage.

February 6, 2012
Freeways to freedom
Last week, while driving to South Shore, I glanced at the dealer placard on the car ahead of me on the Jesse Stuart Bridge.

February 6, 2012
Lee Ward: 02/05/2012 — Dieting is a man's world
A male coworker is dieting, apparently for the first time.

February 5, 2012
Katie Brandenburg: Finding a time machine: 2/3/12
My grandmother once told me a story about a boy she grew up with who built a time machine in his family’s shed.

February 2, 2012
John Cannon: Not a chore but a true labor of love: 2/1/12
It was a slow and tedious task, but it was anything but work.

January 31, 2012
Cathie Shaffer: A whiff of the past: 1/31/12
It occurred to me, as I listened to a conversation about today’s home medical treatments versus yesterday’s, that one big factor is the smell.

January 31, 2012
TIM PRESTON: Downtown scenes, Valentine’s dinner, bacon and running
Tim Preston's weekly business column for Jan. 29.

January 30, 2012
More Columns Headlines

Columns

Search Results

Discussion

MARK MAYNARD: Goodell made right call on Stallworth 6/20/09

Site Map

Contact Us