I’ve been keeping a wary eye on the filming of celebrity chef Jamie Oliver’s quote, unquote reality TV show in Huntington.
I’m having some fairly mixed feelings about it, too.
In case you haven’t been keeping up, Oliver, as he done in the past in his native Britain, is doing a program geared toward improving peoples’ dietary habits, with the goal of getting them to eat better and live healthier lifestyles.
Huntington was apparently chosen as the location for the as-yet-untitled, six-episode series, which will air next year on ABC, because it was labeled “America’s unhealthiest city” in an Associated Press story last year.
And that brings me to my first problem with the show — it’s based on a designation that is, at worst, inaccurate, and at best, highly misleading.
The story that caught the attention of Oliver’s production company was based on an AP analysis of data contained in a 2006 report from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. But herein lies the problem — the CDC report drew on data for a metropolitan service area that includes five counties, and of which Ashland is also a part.
So is it fair that Huntington proper has to bear the entire burden of being the fattest city in the nation? I don’t think so.
Having said that, though, it should also be noted that a recent report by the Gallup-Healthways Well Being Index showed that West Virginia does, indeed, have the highest rate of diabetes in the nation, and the second-highest obesity rate. But again, that’s the entire state, not just Huntington.
For his part, Oliver has said it’s not his intent to make anyone look bad. But, public comments he has made about the program have done little to allay residents’ concerns.
In a recent interview with the British Sky News service, Oliver said essentially that the people he’d met, while not stupid or ignorant, were information-poor because they lacked information about healthy eating and cooking from scratch.
I’ve seen some postings on Facebook, too, from friends discussing the filming of the show that haven’t exactly been glowing.
There were reports that during a visit to Huntington High School, Oliver berated one student for getting two chocolate milks for lunch. And that he instructed another to act upset when he took his French fries away from him. And that he intentionally selected only the heaviest kids to interview.
Oh, yeah — in a rather ironic twist, one poster said his son informed him that the members of Oliver’s camera crew aren’t exactly svelte themselves.
At any rate, like I said at the outset, I’ve got some seriously mixed feelings about this whole venture.
As an Appalachian myself, I find the notion that people in Appalachia are a bunch of bumpkins who need a British chef to tell them how to eat healthy to be, well, rather offensive.
On the other hand, I also recognize that obesity is a serious public health concern and that poor eating habits are often at the root of the problem.
If the program gets folks to wake up and take stock of their own diets, with eyes toward making improvements, it will have accomplished a noble goal.
I just hope it manages to do so without trashing our region too badly in the process.
KENNETH HART can be reached at khart@dailyindependent.com or (606) 326-2654.
Columns
KENNETH HART: 101809
- Columns
-
-
Mark Maynard: Charles will be in charge: 2/9/12
It was at least mildly interesting a couple of weeks ago when the deadline for filing for local elected offices came and went without much fanfare.
-
John Cannon: After passion, love still grows: 2/8/12
While a naive student at Morehead State University more than 40 years ago, my then girlfriend made me an offer I could not refuse. It was only later that I learned I should have refused it.
-
Cathie Shaffer: All that’s old is new again: 02/07/12
Every night before I go to bed, I click on my electric blanket. There’s nothing I like better on a cold — OK, lately, it’s been coolish — night than a nice, warm bed.
-
Tim Preston: Art downtown, ‘hippie’ soap, Valentine’s and living-dead machines: 02/05/12
I’m not certain this is anything that could be classified as a trend, although I have noticed something in downtown Ashland I am compelled to encourage.
-
Freeways to freedom
Last week, while driving to South Shore, I glanced at the dealer placard on the car ahead of me on the Jesse Stuart Bridge.
-
Lee Ward: 02/05/2012 — Dieting is a man's world
A male coworker is dieting, apparently for the first time.
-
Katie Brandenburg: Finding a time machine: 2/3/12
My grandmother once told me a story about a boy she grew up with who built a time machine in his family’s shed.
-
John Cannon: Not a chore but a true labor of love: 2/1/12
It was a slow and tedious task, but it was anything but work.
-
Cathie Shaffer: A whiff of the past: 1/31/12
It occurred to me, as I listened to a conversation about today’s home medical treatments versus yesterday’s, that one big factor is the smell.
-
TIM PRESTON: Downtown scenes, Valentine’s dinner, bacon and running
Tim Preston's weekly business column for Jan. 29.
- More Columns Headlines
-
Mark Maynard: Charles will be in charge: 2/9/12








