Seeking balance — 06/17/09 » Editorials » Daily Independent (Ashland, KY)

Editorials

Discussion

June 16, 2009

Seeking balance — 06/17/09

Obama administration puts curbs on mountaintop mining

Anonymous The Daily Independent Tue Jun 16, 2009, 06:15 PM EDT

In announcing steps to reduce the environmental destruction caused by mountaintop coal mining, President Barack Obama said he is attempting to establish clear standards that will ensure the environment, economy and health of Appalachia are adequately protected. Finding that balance between the environment and the economy could well be the president’s biggest challenge.

Unfortunately, like so many environmental issues, the debate over mountaintop coal mining had largely been dominated by those with the most extreme positions, while those of us who believe the best answer lies somewhere in between the two extremes have been largely ignored.

To members of environmental organizations like Kentuckians For the Commonwealth, all mountaintop removal projects cause permanent damage to the environment and the mining process should be completely banned.

However, to coal companies, mountaintop is the most cost-effective way of getting to the coal, and outlawing the process would make it economically unfeasible to mine millions of tons of coal that form the economic backbone of eastern Kentucky. In many rural counties of eastern Kentucky, the only good paying jobs are in coal mining, and banning mountaintop mining would only increase the poverty in what already is one of the poorest regions of the nation.

In addition, supporters say mountaintop mining has created thousands of acres of what is a real premium in the mountains: Level land. That land can be used for development. One needs look no further than the Paul Coffey Industrial Park in Boyd County to see what can be created on land leveled by strip mining.

It’s too early to tell just what impact the changes announced last week by the Obama administration will have on mountaintop mining, but at first glance, we think they will be positive. The administration of George W. Bush was too eager to issue mountaintop mining permits and tried to permanently change the regulations to make it easier for coal companies to get the permits.

The Obama administration has put the brakes on those changes. That’s a positive — as long as it does not go too far to the other extreme.

Nancy Sutley, head of the White House Council on Environmental Quality, said the Interior Department, the Environmental Protection Agency and the Army Corps of Engineers will set clear standards, ensuring that communities in coal-mining regions have clean streams and drinking water.

“The Obama administration has serious concerns about the impacts of mountaintop coal mining on our natural resources and on the health and welfare of Appalachian communities,” Sutley said. “Within this plan the Obama administration is doing all it can under existing laws and regulations to curb the most environmentally destructive impacts of mountaintop coal mining.”

Good. Such changes are needed. We’re not opposed on all mountaintop removal mining, but we do think it should be the exception instead of the rule in determining how best to mine coal.

The administration’s announcement last week pleased neither coal mining companies nor environmentalists. Coal companies fear that it again will be too difficult to get permits to do mountaintop mining, while environmentalists expressed disappointment that the administration did not totally ban mountaintop removal mining.

“The administration’s current plan is a good first step. ... We would like leaps,” said Janet Keating, executive director of the Ohio Valley Environmental Coalition.

When a new policy upsets those on both sides of an issue, that’s often a sign that the policy is the right one. We hope that’s the case this time.

Text Only

Editorials

Earmarks again?
Immediately, following the midterm elections of 2010 which saw Republicans regain control of the House of Representatives and capture seats in the U.S. Senate, Republican leaders in Congress announced they had heard the voice of the voters and vowed to cease using “earmarks,” the name given to appropriations slipped into bills by influential legislators without a vote.

May 26, 2012
Best in the nation
It may surprise many readers that Newsweek’s “best high school in America” is located right here in Kentucky and is open to selected students throughout the state, but then the Carol Martin Gatton Academy of Mathematics and Science at Western Kentucky University in Bowling Green is hardly your typical high school. In fact, it would be impossible for even the best public high schools to emulate the amazing success of students at the Gatton Academy.

May 25, 2012
After the vote
We offer today a few reflections on the messages voters sent in Tuesday’s primary election in Kentucky.

May 24, 2012
A mild winter
As we approach the Memorial Day weekend, long hailed as the unofficial start of the summer vacation season, we pause to reflect upon the winter that wasn’t.

May 23, 2012
Devices banned
Emergency breathing devices that tests have proven unreliable are being phased out under a directive issued by the federal Mine Safety and Health Administration. However, MSHA has given mine operators more than 18 months to remove all the air packs from underground mines.

May 22, 2012
A free weekend
In an effort to promote increased recreational use of the two lakes in the Daniel Boone National Forest, the U.S. Forest Service will offer free fishing and boating during the first weekend in June.

May 22, 2012
Ho-hum election
Psst! Want to know a secret? There’s a primary election Tuesday. And it’s right here in Kentucky! However, there has been so little interest in this election, that Secretary of State Alison Lundergan Grimes, the state’s top election official, is predicting that only betwixen 10 and 12 percent of the state’s eligible voters will take the time to go to the polls tomorrow.

May 21, 2012
A real rush job
By giving first reading approval to two identical ordinances creating the Northeast Regional Jail Authority, elected leaders in Boyd and Carter counties are reviving a 30-year-old political issue — only this time with different results.

May 20, 2012
KCTC leads way
The ability of Kentucky to compete with other states and the rest of the world for the good jobs of tomorrow keeps improving by degrees.

May 19, 2012
Slow decline?
Louisville’s Churchill Downs is seeing its shortest spring meets since 1975, and some owners, trainers and breeders fear they could get even shorter. That is unless the Kentucky General Assembly has a change of heart and gives the home of the Kentucky Derby the option of increasing its nonracing revenue by offering new forms of gambling.

May 18, 2012
More Editorials Headlines

Editorials

Search Results

Discussion

Seeking balance — 06/17/09

Obama administration puts curbs on mountaintop mining

Site Map

Contact Us