Still a good idea

Editorials

Discussion

March 10, 2013

Still a good idea

House should accept Senate change to taxing district bill

Anonymous The Independent The Daily Independent Sun Mar 10, 2013, 06:00 AM EDT

ASHLAND — Kentucky Auditor Adam Edelen does not like the changes the Senate made to a House-approved bill increasing oversight to the more than 1,200 taxing districts, but if that’s what it takes to get the law approved, the Kentucky House of Representatives should compromise and agree to those changes.

The bill is too important to be allowed to fail over an amendment for which we suspect many, if not most Kentuckians would be in agreement.

The provisions included in House Bill 1 would not be high on any legislator’s agenda if not for Edelen. Before becoming auditor in January of 2012, the special taxing districts that fund libraries, voluntary fire departments, soil conservation districts and other tax-supported entities had drawn only scant attention from state and county elected officials and from taxpayers.

But soon after becoming auditor, Edelen’s office launched a study of taxing districts that found the 1,268 taxing districts collect $1.5 billion in taxes and fees each year, plus another $1 billion in grants and private donations. He said the districts also hold about $1.3 billion in reserves. Because they’ve operated with little oversight, Edelen said called the taxing districts a “ghost government.”

Based largely on Edelen’s findings, House Speaker Greg Stumbo, D-Prestonsburg, sponsored the bill designed to give the taxing districts the oversight they needed and that the people belatedly demanded. Besides improved oversight, Stumbo’s proposal would create a centralized registry for taxing districts so that taxpayers and government agencies will know how many of them exist in Kentucky. And it would require leaders of local taxing districts to undergo ethics training and to answer to a local ethics commission, just as other government officials do.

With the full support of the appointed leaders of most taxing districts, HB 1 sailed through the House of Representatives by a vote of 96-1.

The Senate was expected to approve the bill with little or no changes. That is until at the insistence of Senate Majority Leader Damon Thayer, R-Georgetown, the Senate State and Local Government Committee amended the House bill to give elected county commissioners and magistrates the power to veto increases in taxes and fees imposed by local taxing districts.

Thayer insisted that the provision is crucial to the bill in that it gives elected officials the right to strike down hikes in taxes and fees, rather than leaving that to the sole discretion of appointees. “For me, it’s a deeply held philosophical belief that taxpayer dollars should not be expended unless there is some kind of oversight component by those who are elected by the people,” he said.

While it may come as a surprise to Edelen and the Democratic majority in the House, many Kentuckians also agree with Thayer. Tax increases should be approved by the people they elect, not by those dedicated but mostly unknown people who serve as appointed members of the boards of the special districts.

Edelen is irate over the Senate change saying that it could jeopardize the support of a broad coalition of local officials who has been pushing the legislation.

“To have that potentially jeopardized and lost over something that isn’t even germane to the bill that we have proposed, I think, represents a sad occasion,” Edelen said.

And to have a good bill fail to become law because legislators do not trust the elected leaders of county governments to have the wisdom to fairly judge the needs of local taxing districts would be an even sadder occasion. While we have not always been impressed by the wisdom — or lack thereof — displayed by members of county fiscal courts, they are elected by the people to serve their interests.

We think House Bill 1 is a good bill without the changes made by the Senate, but if that is what is takes to approve the bill, then so be it. As we understand it, the change would not allow fiscal courts to slash the taxes of the special districts; it would just give the power to prevent any tax hikes. That’s not unreasonable.

The House is scheduled to vote Monday on the amended Senate version. Let us hope reason prevails.

Text Only

Editorials

Funding Rupp
The use of $2.5 million in coal severance tax revenue to help pay for renovations at Rupp Arena in Lexington has drawn the ire of some county leaders in the eastern Kentucky coalfields.

June 19, 2013
Modest increase
Full-time students at Ashland Community and Technical College will be paying an average of $60 more in tuition this fall under a modest 2.86 percent increase approved Friday by the Kentucky Community and Technical College System Board of Regents.

June 19, 2013
The next step
The people — or at least those who took the time to vote in Tuesday’s special election — have spoken. The issue of alcohol sales in Grayson has ben settled for at least the next three years.
In an outcome that surprised many, Grayson voters rather convincingly for the legal sale of alcohol in the city for the first time since 1937. With 511 voters answering in the affirmative to the question, “Are you in favor of alcoholic beverages in Grayson, Ky.?” as opposed to 393 voting “no,” the results were not even close. The measure passed in all seven of the city’s precincts.

June 16, 2013
Top Father
In the Spade family, the vote was unanimous. Both 12-year-old Emma Spade, who will be a seventh-grader at Verity Middle School this fall, and Emma’s 11-year-old brother Will, who attends Hagar Elementary, both thought so highly of their dad — Ponderosa Elementary School principal Matt Spade — that they both wrote essays nominating him for the Ashland Breakfast Kiwanis Club’s annual Father of the Year award, presented annually on the Tuesday before Father’s Day.

June 15, 2013
An unselfish act
Even before the start of the recent Boyd County Health Department’s Bicycle Rodeo, Gavin Eckard said that if he won one of the two bicycle given away at the event, he would give his new bike to someone who needed it more than he did.

June 14, 2013
Crop still banned
When their colleagues in the U.S. Senate rejected their efforts to legalize industrial hemp production as part of the Senate farm bill, Kentucky’s two Republican senators — Minority Leader Mitch McConnell and freshman Rand Paul — reacted to the Senate refusal to include their hemp proposal in the bill by saying they would oppose the comprehensive farm bill.

June 13, 2013
It's not the breed
Lorie Akers wants the Ashland City Commissioner to adopt an ordinance banning pit bulls in the city. Since she claimed her Chihuahua Paco was attacked and killed by a neighbor’s pit bull while the little dog was chained in the back yard, it is understandable that Akers is worried that her children and other pets could be endangered by pit bulls.

June 12, 2013
A necessary evil
The shifting of the tax burden that began when the Ashland Board of City Commissioners first adopted the payroll tax in the 1990s continues as the mayor and four elected commissioners prepare to increase the payroll tax from 1.5 to 2 percent while at the same time decreasing property taxes.

June 11, 2013
No time to read
The complaints of two leading legislators about a provision added to a complex pension reform bill approved by the 3013 Kentucky General Assembly points hat can happen when legislative leaders wait until the final days or even hour of a legislative session to bring major pieces of legislation. In so doing, they force legislators to vote on bills they have not even had time to read.

June 10, 2013
To the polls
On Tuesday, residents of Grayson will discover if attitudes about the sale of alcohol in the city have changed in the past 42 years. It is an important question, and we encourage registered voters to take the time to go to the polls Tuesday.

June 9, 2013
More Editorials Headlines

Editorials

Search Results

Discussion

Still a good idea

House should accept Senate change to taxing district bill

Site Map

Contact Us