SALT LAKE CITY — A federal judge said Friday he's reluctant to put global warming on trial in the case of a Utah college student charged with disrupting a federal oil and gas lease auction for parcels near several national parks.
U.S. District Judge Dee Benson gave attorneys for Tim DeChristopher a month to file briefs saying why they should be allowed claim he was acting in the interest of the greater good.
DeChristopher says he posed as a bidder last December — and indeed won $1.7 million in leases — in an act of civil disobedience to protect wild lands near Utah's national parks from drilling and call attention to climate change.
After a 45-minute hearing, Benson didn't rule out the possibility of DeChristopher's so-called "lesser-of-two-evils" defense but said he's reluctant to "open this courtroom to a lengthy hearing on global warming."
Federal prosecutors say DeChristopher's case should be decided strictly on whether or not he's guilty of felony counts of interfering with and making false representations at a government auction. DeChristopher has pleaded not guilty.
Assistant U.S. Attorney John Huber told Benson that DeChristopher's case doesn't meet several key hurdles established by case law that justifies the "necessity" defense for crimes done in the name of a greater good. Those requirements include proof of imminent harm and a lack of any other legal means to arrive at the same result.
"The political process works in this country," Huber said. "We don't resort to criminal acts."
The defense's intent is to widen the scope of the trial into a publicized philosophical discussion over global warming and environmental damage, Huber said. Those points are irrelevant to the charges, he said.
But DeChristopher's attorney, Ronald Yengich, compared his client to Rosa Parks and civil rights activists known as the Freedom Riders.
He said the Bush administration in its waning days tried to illegally auction off parcels in some of Utah's most pristine environments. DeChristopher's disruption of the auction was a nonviolent effort "to stop what he believed was greater harm."
"This man had no other option in his mind," Yengich said.
He said he'd like to have evidentiary hearings including scientists, legal experts and other witnesses who can talk about climate change, oil and gas drilling, and other larger issues related to the case.
Asked after the hearing whether he wants to put global warming on trial, Yengich said: "I'd like to put the Bush administration on trial."
DeChristopher, now a senior economics major at the University of Utah, has become a hero in some environmental circles for his stand against global warming. Although he faces the possibility of prison if convicted, he said Friday he has no regrets.
"This is a serious threat that justifies strong action," he said after the hearing.
At the Dec. 19 BLM auction, DeChristopher grabbed a bidder's paddle to run up prices and take parcels between Arches and Canyonlands national parks for safekeeping. He later acknowledged he didn't have $1.7 million to pay for his leases on 22,000 acres.
DeChristopher faces up to 10 years in prison if convicted, although the U.S. attorney in Utah has said he is unlikely to get anything close to the maximum punishment.
DeChristopher had been scheduled to go to trial last summer, but motions over what kind of defense can be used have delayed the proceedings.
Many of the original 77 leases were scrapped in February by new Interior Secretary Ken Salazar, who has said the Bush administration in its final weeks rushed to sell the oil and gas leases "at the doorstep of some of our greatest national icons, some of our nation's most treasured landscapes."
A federal review team this summer said some of the leases would clearly spoil views from some of Utah's national parks, while others could prove suitable for sale again because they're near existing or soon-to-be-operating oil and gas fields.
Science/Environment
September 28, 2009
Judge averse to global warming trial in Utah case
- Science/Environment
-
- Clean-coal project pushing for help from lawmakers Backers of the proposed $2 billion Cash Creek coal-gasification project in western Kentucky asked lawmakers Thursday to pass legislation that would force utilities to purchase the higher-priced electricity it would generate.
-
Coal legislators defend industry as activists call for change
Coal came under attack Thursday in Frankfort from a citizen activist group but not much is likely to change according to some key lawmakers.
- Grayson airs TV ad attacking Rand Paul on coal Republican Trey Grayson paints himself as pro-coal and pegs the perceived frontrunner in the U.S. Senate race as unfriendly to the mining industry in a political ad airing in the mining region of eastern Kentucky.
- Beleaguered US to blow up its chemical stockpiles Under the gun to destroy the U.S. chemical weapons stockpile — and now all but certain to miss their deadline — Army officials have a plan to hasten the process: Blow some of them up.
-
Appalachian strip mines have long-term environmental effect
Reclaimed surface mines in Central Appalachia have continuing environmental impact after their reclamation bonds are released but are not commonly monitored by state and federal regulators, says a new report from the Government Accountability Office.
- UN climate chief quits, leaves talks hanging The sharp-tongued U.N. official who shepherded troubled climate talks for nearly four years announced his resignation Thursday, leaving an uncertain path to a new treaty on global warming.
- Ky. National Guard adds solar panels to facility The Kentucky National Guard is going green.
- Bees impacted by mountaintop removal coal mining Mountaintop removal coal mining is destroying the flowering trees and plants that honey bees depend on for food in the central Appalachians.
-
Cold Spring man has eye on the sky
Fred Calvert doesn't have to go far for a view that's out of this world.
-
Still time for public to comment on Ky.'s forest
Kentuckians with an interest in the state's trees and forests are being asked to comment on a draft report that outlines forest-related issues.
- More Science/Environment Headlines




